
Does Car Insurance Cover Hitting a Deer in Illinois?
Yes, if your policy has comprehensive coverage. On most car insurance policies, hitting a deer is a comprehensive claim. You pay your deductible, and the policy pays the rest of the covered repair.
If you only have liability insurance, the repair to your own car is on you. Here is how it works in Illinois, and what to do if a deer jumps out in front of you this fall.
When is deer crash season in Illinois?
Deer are most active from October through December, mainly at dawn and dusk. That comes from IDOT and the Illinois Department of Natural Resources, who call this the peak season for deer crashes.
In 2021, more than 42% of Illinois deer crashes happened in October, November and December. November was the highest risk month.
The IDOT 2024 Illinois Crash Facts and Statistics report counted 14,426 crashes involving deer that year. Of those, 61.8% happened in darkness.
Do deer crashes happen in the suburbs too?
They do. In 2021 Cook County had more deer crashes than any other county in Illinois, with 493, per IDOT. Kane County, just west of Schaumburg, came in sixth with 299.
Is hitting a deer comprehensive or collision?
Hitting a deer counts as comprehensive on most policies. Insurance companies put an animal strike in the same group as hail, theft or a fallen tree branch.
Swerving changes that. If you miss the deer and hit a guardrail, a ditch or another car, that becomes a collision claim. Collision has its own deductible, and it only pays if you have collision on your policy.
IDOT tells drivers not to veer for deer. A sudden swerve can make you lose control and end up in another lane or off the road.
What if you only have liability insurance?
Liability insurance pays for damage you cause to other people and their property. It pays nothing toward your own car. With liability only, the repair after a deer strike comes out of your pocket.
Dropping to liability only on an older car can make sense. Just know what it leaves out before November gets here.
How does the deductible work on a deer claim?
Your deductible is the part of the repair you pay before insurance pays the rest. You pick that amount when you buy the policy.
A higher deductible lowers your price, but you pay more out of pocket after a crash. A lower deductible costs more each month and leaves you less to pay when something happens.
If the repair costs less than your deductible, the claim does not pay anything. That is why many people pay for a small deer dent themselves.
What should you do after you hit a deer?
IDOT and the Illinois DNR give these first steps:
- Pull off to the shoulder and turn on your hazard lights.
- Call 911 to report the crash.
- Do not get out to check on a hurt deer or pull it from the road.
Once you are safe, do this too:
- Take photos of your car, the road and the damage from a few angles.
- Write down the police report number if an officer comes out.
- Call us at (847) 238-3861 and we will help you start the claim.
Can you take home a deer you hit in Illinois?
Yes, if you live in Illinois. The Illinois DNR road kill page says the driver gets first claim to a deer killed or hurt in the crash. People who live out of state cannot claim one.
If you take the deer, you have to report it within 24 hours on the DNR’s online form. You cannot sell or trade any part of it.
Only law enforcement may kill a deer that a car has hurt. Leave that to the officer who comes out.
How can you avoid deer on northwest suburb roads?
The DNR points out that deer move most around dawn and dusk, which are busy driving times. In late fall, that lines up with a lot of commutes in and around Schaumburg.
IDOT shares these tips for deer season:
- Watch closely in areas with deer crossing signs.
- Scan the sides of the road for eye shine, the glow of your headlights in a deer’s eyes.
- Slow down when you see a deer. They travel in groups, so more are likely nearby.
- Be ready for a deer to stop in the middle of the road or double back.
- If a crash cannot be avoided, do not veer. Try to glance off the deer and avoid swerving into other lanes or off the road.
Check your policy before November
Look at the first page of your auto policy, called the declarations page. If you do not see comprehensive listed, ask us what adding it would cost.
Our page on auto insurance in Schaumburg explains collision, comprehensive and uninsured motorist side by side. It helps you see which ones fit your car.
Call us at (847) 238-3861 or stop by the office on Roselle Road. We help drivers in English and in Spanish, and we are open Saturdays too.
Categories: Blog






